My Lai a Brief History With Documents Review

• Home
• My Books

Open Preview

See a Problem?

We'd dear your help. Permit united states know what's incorrect with this preview of My Lai by James Stuart Olson.

Thanks for telling us almost the problem.

Friend Reviews

To encounter what your friends thought of this volume, please sign upwards.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions nigh My Lai, delight sign upwards.

Exist the starting time to ask a question well-nigh My Lai

Community Reviews

 · 206 ratings  · thirteen reviews

Start your review of My Lai: A Brief History with Documents

Mar 28, 2021 Gray♡ rated it actually liked it

i had to read this for course and so i wasn't too excited about it at first. Now that i've finished it, i can say i am surprised at how much i liked information technology. It was a very detailed drove of documents detailing the heartbreaking event. Ultimately, everyone should know about the events that took identify in My Lai.

February 19, 2022 Eric rated it really liked information technology

harrowing stuff, smashing insights and presentation

Jun 16, 2017 Ted rated it really liked it

Lt William Calley was a horribly inept platoon leader. He was likewise a war crimes criminal and should have been hung for his actions. To be found guilty of killing unarmed men, women and, specially, children and ultimately only serving iii 1/2 years under house arrest for these awful actions is justice denied. That said, Calley was besides a scapegoat. He was the simply individual to be found guilty of this genocidal incident. His company commander, Capt Earnest Medina (who ordered his troops to des Lt William Calley was a horribly inept platoon leader. He was also a state of war crimes criminal and should accept been hung for his actions. To be establish guilty of killing unarmed men, women and, especially, children and ultimately only serving 3 ane/two years under firm arrest for these atrocious actions is justice denied. That said, Calley was also a scapegoat. He was the only individual to be found guilty of this genocidal incident. His company commander, Capt Hostage Medina (who ordered his troops to destroy everything in the village that was "walking, itch or growing") and all in the chain of command above that contributed to the coverup of the massacre in My Lai (Son My) all bore blame for this mass killing of some 5oo unarmed villagers.

My Lai was certainly non an isolated incident, just for the National Liberation Front Commission of Quang Nai province to proclaim that this "was the almost barbaric killing in human history" is ludicrous. I'm before long reading Mark Bowden's account of the Tet offensive of 1968 and the capture of Hue urban center past the Viet Cong and NVA forces (Hue 1968). Nearly 3000 civilians were executed by their northern "liberators". Many were found with their hands bound behind their backs with single gunshots to their heads. Others were plant to have been buried while still alive. Barbaric killings indeed. So innocents died by the hands of both sides during this sad and tragic war. Olson's book covers one such deplorable atrocity.

...more

Mar 31, 2016 Romaissa rated it really liked it

"How tin I like a volume that filled me with so much rage?" I pondered as I was picking out my rating. And I realized, it'due south not the content. It's the truth that it presents. I read this for my American History grade and fifty-fifty used it to write an essay on the reasons for this tragedy and what its comprehend upward etc. says virtually the nature of the Vietnam War, in general. I liked that these were primary documents that I was analyzing for the most part; not 2nd hand analysis from historians (though those mos "How can I like a book that filled me with so much rage?" I pondered as I was picking out my rating. And I realized, it's not the content. It's the truth that it presents. I read this for my American History course and fifty-fifty used it to write an essay on the reasons for this tragedy and what its cover up etc. says about the nature of the Vietnam War, in general. I liked that these were principal documents that I was analyzing for the most part; not 2nd mitt analysis from historians (though those most definitely have their value and esteemed place, especially for clarifying context). I ended with the sad belief that My Lai was not an isolated outcome; as the nature of war cannot e'er be completely pure and honest (it'due south my more than pacifist side speaking hither). Overall, if yous wish to larn near My Lai and the Vietnam War, this is a book I recommend. ...more than

January fifteen, 2015 Theresa rated it really liked it

James S. Olson chose great documents and interesting interviews to inform us readers about this atrocity that happened merely several decades agone. There were also some pictures that added more emotional content to the book, showing how terrible the massacre was. I enjoyed reading this volume and would definitely recommend it to anyone who doesn't want to read to much but nevertheless want to get a lot of information out.

Likewise, a pocket-size side notation, Olson does a fantastic job with giving the background informa

James S. Olson chose great documents and interesting interviews to inform us readers about this atrocity that happened just several decades ago. There were besides some pictures that added more emotional content to the book, showing how terrible the massacre was. I enjoyed reading this volume and would definitely recommend it to anyone who doesn't want to read to much but still desire to get a lot of information out.

Also, a small side note, Olson does a fantastic task with giving the background information and organizing each document in his book.

...more than

The merely reason this volume did not get 5 stars is because the few pictures that were included had no explanation. I looked on the Internet and learned and then much more. I was besides shocked at how much I found myself disliking Calley, only to discover he was 26. How tin someone who has just entered machismo make such decisions and be held culpable?

Splendid for what it'south meant for. Total of information, thought provoking at the very least. I, personally, am partial to fiction, notwithstanding, and so while it's factual and a proficient source for the history essay I read it for, it'south not a book I would sit and read for fun. First-class for what it'south meant for. Full of data, thought provoking at the very least. I, personally, am partial to fiction, however, and so while it'southward factual and a practiced source for the history essay I read it for, it's not a book I would sit and read for fun. ...more

May 21, 2016 Isaac rated it information technology was astonishing

This was a very pitiful book in my opinion. It talked virtually Charlie company going into a village and killing about five hundred innocent men,women,and children. Thinking they were Viet Cong. I dear the information it has only non the outcome. It is a must read book.

This book was very helpful and informative. Though, in my opinion, the multiple interviews became repetitive and deadening.

Oct 23, 2012 Chris rated it really liked it

Excellent book if a chip lengthy. Students reply to it well and information technology does a great job at facilitating discussions on My Lai and the broader nature of war and military civilisation.

December fourteen, 2008 Alma rated it it was amazing

A must read for every American who needs a clearer picture virtually what truly went on in Vietnam.

News & Interviews

Need another alibi to care for yourself to a new book this week? Nosotros've got you covered with the buzziest new releases of the day. To create our...

Welcome dorsum. Just a moment while we sign y'all in to your Goodreads account.

mcwilliamswhimeldreved.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/474285.My_Lai

Share this post